Hickory Ground History

FULL HISTORY Internal Page

The entire History and Info

Before the desecration, for millennia before the Removal Treaty of 1832, the Muscogee (Creek) people inhabited most of what is now Alabama. The Muscogee (Creek) Nation was composed of Tribal Towns, including the Tribal Town site called Ocevpofv by the Muscogee (Creek) people, and known as “Hickory Ground Tribal Town” by English speakers.

Hickory Ground is of major importance in the history of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, Hickory Ground Tribal Town, and the United States. It was the last tribal capital of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation prior to removal. Hickory Ground was critical to the very formation of the United States. When European nations questioned the sovereignty of the newly born United States, President George Washington lent legitimacy to the nascent country by signing treaties with Indian Nations, including the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, whose sovereignty had previously been affirmed through treaties with France, Spain, and England. Thus, in 1790, nearly two centuries (before Poarch was recognized as a tribe,) President George Washington executed a treaty with the Muscogee (Creek) Nation. The head of the Muscogee treaty delegation was from Hickory Ground.

Because Tribal Town affiliation is matrilineal, the current members of Hickory Ground Tribal Town in Oklahoma are the lineal descendants of the ancestors buried at the historic Hickory Ground in Wetumpka, Alabama.

Each Tribal Town is led by its chief, or mekko. Mekko George Thompson is the kosa mekko of Hickory Ground, and has been since 1977. He is known as kosa mekko, or Coosa Chief, as Hickory Ground dates back to the first Tribal Town at the time of the beginnings, known as kosa or Coosa. Since time immemorial, Mekko Thompson’s ancestors have served as Mekko of Hickory Ground Tribal Town.

Where is Hickory Ground and What is There?

Hickory Ground is located on the east bank of the Coosa River, south of the present-day Wetumpka and approximately two miles north of Fort Toulouse.

Hickory Ground Tribal Town, like all Tribal Towns of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, contains a ceremonial ground (square ground), council house, plaza, burial sites, and individual graves containing human remains and funerary objects of the ancestors of the Plaintiffs. Hickory Ground has profound cultural and religious importance to the Plaintiffs.

What is Hickory Ground Now?

Hickory Ground is a state-registered archaeological site (1EE89) and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Hickory Ground was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980, after the Alabama State Historic Commission applied for its placement on the Register on behalf of Poarch. The part of Hickory Ground listed on the National Register of Historic Places and currently considered to be trust or reservation land is referred to herein as the “Hickory Ground Site.”

History of the Poarch Band of Creek Indians

The Poarch Band of Creek Indians is allegedly made of individuals who descended from the Muscogee (Creek) Nation as it existed in the early 1800s. During the early 1800s, the Muscogee (Creek) Nation was principally located in what is now known as the state of Alabama, and was made up of several independent groups called tribal towns.

In the early 1800s, several white settlers married Muscogee (Creek) women and settled in a small geographic area known as Tensaw, located in southwest Alabama. When the United States government removed the Muscogee (Creek) Nation from Alabama in the 1830s, many of those living at the Tensaw settlement chose not to remain with the Nation. As the Indian Claims Commission put it, these “remaining members of the [Muscogee (Creek) Nation] abandoned all tribal organization and became United States citizens.”

Thus, the descendants of the Creek individuals who stayed in Alabama “maintained no tribal organization” and simply existed as “unorganized descendants” until the Indian Claims Commission proceedings arose in the 1950s. McGhee v. Creek Nation, 122 Ct. Cl. 380, 385, 388, 391 (1952), cert. denied, 344 U.S. 856 (1952).

The Indian Claims Commission proceedings presented an opportunity for the unorganized descendants in Alabama to obtain compensation for lands ceded by the Muscogee (Creek) Nation in 1814, a time when their Creek ancestors located in Tensaw were still considered part of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation. The facts suggest that the unorganized descendants attempted to create a tribal organization solely for the purpose of monetary gain. The Indian Claims Commission observed in 1952 that the “Creek Nation East of the Mississippi” (which later rebranded itself as the “Poarch Band of Creek Indians”) was a “recently formed tribal organization.”

The BIA granted recognition to the Poarch Band of Creek Indians in 1984. See Memorandum from Deputy Assistant Secretary – Indian Affairs to Assistant Secretary – Indian Affairs entitled “Recommendation and summary of evidence for proposed finding for Federal acknowledgment of the Poarch Band of Creeks of Alabama pursuant to 25 C.F.R. 83” (Dec. 29, 1983). The Muscogee (Creek) Nation wrote a letter in support. It is unclear whether much research was done by the Nation at the time it extended this support.

Poarch’s Acquisition of Hickory Ground in 1980

Poarch obtained the Hickory Ground site in 1980 with $165,000 in federal preservation grant funds and a $165,000 donation from the landowner. In the same year, pursuant to standard terms of federal preservation grant awards, a protective covenant was placed on the property for 20 years. Poarch had never occupied Hickory Ground prior to 1980.

Poarch stated that its purpose in acquiring the Hickory Ground Site was to preserve the historic property for the benefit of all Creek Indians, including the “existing Hickory Ground tribal town in Oklahoma,” and to preserve the Site “without excavation.”

In its application for the $165,000 federal preservation grant to purchase the Hickory Ground Site, Poarch stated that “Hickory Ground (site no. 1-Ee-89) is of major importance in the history of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation. It has supplied many of the important leaders in Creek history. Hickory Ground was involved in nearly all the major historic events in the southeast before the removal of Creeks from Alabama in 1836,” including significant battles fought by Andrew Jackson.

In the section of its Federal Preservation Grant Application titled “The Use Of The Land,” Poarch unequivocally represented and promised that “The property will serve as a valuable resource for cultural enrichment of Creek people… The Creek people in Oklahoma pride in heritage and ties to original homeland can only be enhanced. There is still an existing Hickory Ground tribal town in Oklahoma. They will be pleased to know their home in Alabama is being preserved… The Hickory Ground site will continue to enhance their understanding of their history, without excavation.”

Poarch’s Desecration of Hickory Ground

When Poarch acquired the Hickory Ground site with federal preservation funds in 1980, a 20-year protective covenant was imposed that prevented development on the property. The 20-year protective covenant expired in July 2000. The year before the covenant expired, Poarch requested that the National Park Service delegate historic preservation responsibilities to Poarch on “all lands within the exterior boundaries of [Poarch’s] Reservation,” which included the Hickory Ground Site. The National Park Service agreed.

From approximately 2001 to approximately 2011, Poarch caused a significant portion of the Hickory Ground Site to be destroyed to make way for its second casino resort (Poarch already had one in Atmore). Specifically, at Poarch’s direction, archaeologists affiliated with Auburn University conducted a phase III excavation of the Hickory Ground Site. At the time Poarch directed this excavation to take place, it knew—from prior archaeological surveys it commissioned—that “well defined and undisturbed cultural remains,” including human burials, were abundant at the Hickory Ground site.

At least 57 sets of human remains along with their associated funerary objects were exhumed during the phase III excavation. Over 7,000 archaeological features, representing historic and ancient Muscogee (Creek) buildings, houses, ceremonial locations, and other sacred locations, were recorded during the excavation. Because not all cultural items are removed during a phase II excavation and before construction, the construction at Hickory Ground likely destroyed many cultural items forever.

Numerous artifacts were removed from the site, and have been stored in a manner that caused, and is continuing to cause, further damage to the items. Some cultural items, including human remains, are still in storage.

Poarch did not consult with, or obtain consent from, the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, Hickory Ground Tribal Town, or Mekko Thompson before commencing the phase III excavation at Hickory Ground. Poarch first notified the Muscogee (Creek) Nation of the phase III excavation in 2006. By that time, some human remains from the Hickory Ground Site had already been exhumed.

Beginning in 2006, the Muscogee (Creek) Nation and Hickory Ground Tribal Town engaged in a years-long effort to persuade Poarch not to excavate and desecrate the remains of our ancestors and other cultural items and to return any cultural items already excavated from Hickory Ground to their original resting place. This effort eventually failed in 2011.

In 2012, after the excavations were completed, Poarch hurriedly reburied most of those remains and objects away from their final resting places. Poarch purposefully provided late notice of the planned reburial to Mekko Thompson and the Muscogee (Creek) Nation in order to exclude them from the process. At no point did anyone from the Nation agree to reinterment away from the remains’ and associated funerary objects’ original resting place.

On July 11, 2012, Poarch announced plans to construct a $246 million casino resort on Hickory Ground. Poarch moved forward with casino construction in October 2012, issuing a press release stating that “we are being faced with demands to remove ancestral remains that have already been reinterred… We cannot change the fact that remains were found and removed. Those remains are now reinterred and we cannot support disturbing those remains again… [N]o one cares more about the sanctity of our land… than we do.”

Hickory Ground remains a symbol of the resilience and enduring cultural heritage of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation. Its history reflects the broader narrative of Native American struggles, from early European contact and treaty negotiations to forced removal and contemporary efforts to preserve sacred sites. The ongoing efforts to protect Hickory Ground underscore the importance of honoring and respecting indigenous history and cultural heritage.

Timeline

1800s and earlier

Hickory Ground, located in what is now Wetumpka, Alabama, is part of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation’s aboriginal homelands.

1812-1815

The Creek ancestors of present-day Poarch individuals betrayed the Muscogee (Creek) Nation and fought alongside Andrew Jackson against the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, committing many massacres against other citizens of the Muscogee (Creek) Nation. Because they fought alongside the United States and against the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, Poarch’s ancestors were allowed to remain living in Alabama on the condition that they relinquish their citizenship in the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, a condition they voluntarily accepted.

1834

The Muscogee (Creek) Nation is violently and forcibly removed to Indian Territory on the Trail of Tears.

1980

Poarch—then calling itself the “Creek Nation East of the Mississippi”—obtained a large part of the Hickory Ground site.

This purchase of Hickory Ground was free to Poarch, funded half by a federal preservation grant and half by a landowner donation of the parcel. In its application for federal funds, Poarch committed to saving the site from development and protecting it “without excavation.”

1984

Poarch—now going by Poarch Band of Creek Indians—obtains federal recognition, and for the first time ever, constitutes an Indian Tribe.

Early 2000s

Without notifying or consulting with the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, Poarch excavates human remains and funerary objects from over 57 Muscogee ancestors at Hickory Ground to make way for a $246 million casino resort called Wind Creek Wetumpka.

April 2012

Poarch secretly and unilaterally reburies remains at a site different from where they were disinterred.

December 2012

The Muscogee (Creek) Nation files a federal lawsuit in the federal district court for the Middle District of Alabama (located in Montgomery, Alabama) to stop the construction of the casino, alleging that Poarch and the federal government violated the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, National Historic Preservation Act, Archaeological Resources Protection Act, and other laws.

2013-2017

• All defendants file motions to dismiss the case.
• Muscogee (Creek) Nation, Hickory Ground, and Mekko Thompson file a motion for a temporary restraining order to stop construction.
• The defendants file a motion to quash discovery.
• The court does not rule on any substantive motions.

2017-2018

Muscogee (Creek) Nation, Hickory Ground, and Mekko Thompson negotiate with Poarch, culminating in a confidential Preservation Agreement where Poarch pledges not to disturb Hickory Ground’s ceremonial grounds or northern 17 acres. Settlement efforts fail.

June 2019

Muscogee (Creek) Nation seeks court permission to amend their complaint, citing claims like outrage and unjust enrichment related to Poarch’s casino construction over sacred grounds.

March 2021

District Court dismisses the case citing Poarch’s sovereign immunity, prompting an appeal to the Eleventh Circuit Court.

Early 2023

Poarch resumes construction at Hickory Ground despite objections from Muscogee (Creek) Nation, who demand inspection rights to safeguard cultural resources, leading to a standoff.

July 2023

The Muscogee (Creek) Nation, Mekko Thompson, and Hickory Ground Tribal Town file their opening brief.

June 2024

The Muscogee (Creek) Nation continues to await Oral Arguments in their case.